BA Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)
Project Author : Vishnu Prabhu
Introduction
Sustainability and responsible business practices are becoming increasingly important for companies in India. Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations are now mandatory, and they play a central role in building investor confidence, maintaining corporate reputation, and ensuring long-term growth.
This project examines how Indian companies are enhancing their ESG performance, identifies emerging trends across industries, and evaluates the impact of ESG factors on both business and society.
Data Collection and Preparation
For the analysis, data was collected from 10 Indian companies covering a five-year period (2021–2025).
The dataset included:
-
Environmental factors: Carbon emissions and energy consumption
-
Financial indicators: Return on Assets (ROA) and Return on Equity (ROE)
-
Governance details: Industry type, company location, CEO name, and gender
The information was obtained from company reports and reliable financial databases. The dataset was then cleaned for missing or inconsistent values and structured into Excel format for statistical analysis.
Regression Analysis
To study the relationship between ESG factors and financial performance, two regression models were built:
-
Model 1: ROA as the dependent variable
-
Model 2: ROE as the dependent variable
The independent variables in both models were carbon emissions, energy consumption, industry, and location.
Model 1: ROA (Return on Assets)
-
Model strength:
R² = 0.506 → About 51% of variation in ROA explained.
Adjusted R² = 0.363 → After adjusting for predictors, about 36% is explained.
The model is statistically significant overall (p = 0.0018). -
Key findings:
-
Carbon emissions: Negative but not significant. Higher carbon levels did not reliably reduce ROA.
-
Energy use: Positive but not significant. Energy consumption showed no meaningful link to ROA.
-
Industry effect: Companies in the diversified (energy/finance/investments) sector had significantly higher ROA (+1.5 units, p < 0.001). Other industries showed no significant differences.
-
Location: Dropped from the model due to collinearity.
-
-
Interpretation:
Industry type is the strongest driver of ROA. Diversified firms perform better, while environmental factors like carbon and energy do not significantly influence asset returns.
Model 2: ROE (Return on Equity)
-
Model strength:
R² = 0.614 → About 61% of variation explained.
Adjusted R² = 0.502 → About 50% explained after adjustment.
Model is statistically significant (p < 0.001). -
Key findings:
-
Carbon emissions: Negative but not significant. No meaningful link to ROE.
-
Energy use: Positive but not significant. No strong relationship with ROE.
-
Industry effect: Diversified firms again performed strongly (+0.73 units, p < 0.001).
-
Other industries: Auto components, footwear, logistics, maritime, metals, and retail sectors showed no significant differences compared to baseline.
-
Location: Dropped due to collinearity with industry/firm identity.
-
-
Interpretation:
ROE is influenced more by industry type than environmental performance. Diversified companies outperform others, while carbon and energy metrics do not show a direct financial impact in this dataset.
Insights from the Dataset
-
Environmental impact not decisive: Carbon emissions and energy use did not significantly affect either ROA or ROE.
-
Industry as a key driver: The diversified sector (energy, finance, investments) consistently outperformed others in both asset and equity returns.
-
Location effects unclear: Location variables could not be separately analyzed because they were strongly tied to industry or firm identity.
-
Governance gap: All sampled CEOs were male, highlighting a lack of gender diversity in leadership roles.
-
Variation across firms: Some companies consistently generated stronger profitability, while others underperformed.
Key Takeaways
-
ESG is growing in importance, but financial links are evolving.
Environmental disclosures (carbon, energy) currently show limited impact on profitability in the short-to-medium term. -
Industry structure is critical.
Companies in diversified sectors perform significantly better in both ROA and ROE compared to peers. -
Governance and diversity matter.
The absence of female CEOs highlights an area where Indian companies can improve ESG alignment. -
Future research opportunities.
Adding variables like firm size, age, R&D investment, and governance practices could provide deeper insights into ESG–financial performance links.
This analysis highlights that ESG is a strategic necessity for Indian companies, but the measurable financial benefits — especially from environmental metrics — may take time to emerge. For now, industry type and diversification remain the strongest predictors of performance.
Comments
Post a Comment