BA Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)
Project Author Hemadri Sri Veena
1. Introduction
Sustainability and responsible business practices are becoming increasingly important for companies in India. Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors are now mandatory and play a vital role in building investor confidence, maintaining a company’s reputation, and ensuring long-term growth.
This study explores how Indian companies are working to improve their ESG performance, highlights emerging trends across industries, and evaluates the broader impact of these factors on both business and society.
To analyze this, data from 10 Indian companies was collected over a five-year period (2021–2025). The dataset included environmental factors such as carbon emissions and energy consumption, financial indicators like Return on Assets (ROA) and Return on Equity (ROE), and governance details including industry type, company location, CEO name, and CEO gender.
The information was gathered from company annual reports and trusted financial databases. Once collected, the data was cleaned for missing or inconsistent entries and organized into an Excel file for further analysis. This ensured that the dataset was both reliable and structured properly for statistical modeling.
Regression Analysis
Once the dataset was prepared, regression models were built to examine the relationship between ESG factors (carbon emissions and energy consumption) and financial performance (ROA and ROE). The analysis also considered industry, location, and company-level characteristics.
Model 1: ROA (Return on Assets)
The first regression model focused on ROA as the dependent variable.
-
Model strength:
R² = 0.43, meaning about 43% of the variation in ROA can be explained by the chosen predictors. After adjustment for the number of variables, this drops to about 24%, indicating a modest fit. -
Key findings:
-
Carbon emissions and energy consumption showed no significant effect on ROA.
-
Industry influence was mixed. For example, firms in the specialty chemicals sector showed slightly weaker ROA.
-
Location mattered in some cases: Mumbai-based firms tended to perform slightly lower on ROA.
-
At the company level, ECLERX Services stood out with a consistently higher ROA compared to its peers.
-
-
Interpretation:
Environmental intensity (carbon and energy use) is not directly linked to asset efficiency in this dataset. Instead, industry-specific factors and company-level strategies seem to play a stronger role in explaining variations in ROA.
Model 2: ROE (Return on Equity)
The second regression model used ROE as the dependent variable.
-
Model strength:
R² = 0.76, Adjusted R² = 0.72. This shows a strong model fit, explaining more than 70% of the variation in ROE. -
Key findings:
-
Carbon emissions and energy consumption again had no significant effect on ROE.
-
Industry differences were highly significant. Firms in electronics manufacturing, IT, satellite communication, and specialty chemicals all showed systematically lower ROE compared to the baseline industry.
-
Location was an important driver of performance. Firms based in Pune, Mumbai, and Hyderabad consistently outperformed others, while Indore showed no advantage.
-
-
Interpretation:
ROE is strongly shaped by industry type and geographic location, not by environmental intensity. Companies in Pune, for example, had the strongest equity returns, highlighting how location-based advantages (talent pools, ecosystem, infrastructure) can impact profitability.
General Insights from the Dataset
-
Industry spread: The dataset covers diverse sectors — specialty chemicals, electronics manufacturing, IT, satellite communication, and platform services — giving a mix of traditional and technology-driven industries.
-
Location clustering: Most companies are concentrated in India’s metropolitan hubs such as Mumbai, Pune, Hyderabad, Bengaluru, and Kolkata. This reflects how corporate activity remains tied to India’s major cities.
-
Leadership profile: All CEOs in the dataset were male. This lack of gender diversity in leadership remains a noticeable governance gap.
-
Profitability variation: ROA and ROE varied widely. Some companies consistently generated high returns, while others struggled with low or even negligible performance.
-
Environmental footprint: Carbon emissions and energy consumption differed drastically across industries. Manufacturing-intensive sectors like specialty chemicals reported extremely high emissions, while IT and service-based companies showed relatively low values.
Key Takeaways
-
Environmental metrics are not yet decisive.
Carbon emissions and energy consumption do not significantly explain financial performance in the short to medium term. -
Industry matters more than environment.
The type of industry plays a far stronger role in determining profitability. Diversified sectors and certain companies outperform peers consistently. -
Location is critical.
Firms located in Pune, Mumbai, and Hyderabad show significant financial advantages compared to those in other cities. -
Governance gaps remain.
The absence of female CEOs highlights an area for improvement in diversity and governance in Indian corporate leadership.
This analysis shows that while ESG disclosures are increasing in India, environmental factors alone are not yet directly tied to financial success. Instead, industry structure, firm strategy, and geographic location are stronger determinants of performance. As ESG integration matures, and as social and governance factors are studied alongside environmental ones, the financial impacts may become clearer over the long run.
Comments
Post a Comment